{
 "worldview_id": "KUNLUN-TRIPLE-SOURCE-V1.0",
 "title": "昆仑洞天 · 三源世界观",
 "subtitle": "上古原生神话为骨架 · 山海经为地理志 · 三星堆为器物与祭制",
 "version": "V1.0",
 "date": "2026-11-07",
 "did": "DID-BR-000002",
 "trace": "Ω₀⊂⊙∞⊂Ω",
 "thesis": "三源不是并列拼贴，而是各有分工：山海经提供可逐字援引的地理与谱系，昆仑原生神话提供垂直宇宙轴，三星堆器物是这套神话在人间被执行的物质装置。融合的关键不是让三者互相证明，而是让它们各守一层、互不越界。",
 "sources": [
  {
   "id": "SHANHAI_JING",
   "name": "《山海经》",
   "role": "地理志与谱系层",
   "text_layer": "战国至汉成书，非一人一时之作",
   "strength": "文本可逐字援引，是最硬的引证来源",
   "limit": "文本内部存在互异记载（如山名、居所），不可视为单一地理实录"
  },
  {
   "id": "KUNLUN_NATIVE",
   "name": "昆仑原生神话",
   "role": "宇宙骨架层",
   "text_layer": "帝之下都 / 九门九井 / 天柱建木 / 四水 / 南渊",
   "strength": "提供垂直轴与空间秩序，是可三维化的结构",
   "limit": "多为象征结构，无实测尺寸，一切度量属创作取值"
  },
  {
   "id": "SANXINGDUI",
   "name": "三星堆",
   "role": "器物与祭制层",
   "text_layer": "遗址年代约公元前 1600–1000 年；一、二号祭祀坑 1986 年发掘",
   "strength": "有出土记录与实测尺寸，是唯一的实物证据",
   "limit": "无文字自证，所有器物与文献的对应均为后人推测"
  }
 ],
 "axioms": [
  {
   "id": "AX-1",
   "text": "帝不显形。帝只以「帝之下都」的名义存在，全篇不给出帝的形象、言语与动作。",
   "basis": "《海内西经》《西山经》均只称「帝之下都」，未描述帝本身",
   "level": "A"
  },
  {
   "id": "AX-2",
   "text": "垂直为尊。世界的合法性由高度决定：渊最低，都居中，天最高。一切叙事沿这条轴上下运动。",
   "basis": "「昆仑之虚，高万仞」＋「昆仑南渊深三百仞」，高度与深度同时被记载",
   "level": "A"
  },
  {
   "id": "AX-3",
   "text": "门即权限。九门由开明兽守，能上者有限（「非仁羿莫能上冈之岩」）。世界不是开放的，进入需要资格。",
   "basis": "《海内西经》九门开明兽守之＋非仁羿莫能上",
   "level": "A"
  },
  {
   "id": "AX-4",
   "text": "器物即装置。三星堆器物不是神话的插图，而是执行神话的器具：面具使人成为神视，神树接通上下，玉璋递交山川。",
   "basis": "本作设定，非文献或考古结论",
   "level": "C"
  },
  {
   "id": "AX-5",
   "text": "三源不互证。不用器物证明文献，不用文献解释器物。三者只共享同一个空间结构，各自保留自己的证据等级。",
   "basis": "本作方法论约束，为避免考古断言风险而设",
   "level": "C"
  }
 ],
 "cosmos": {
  "layers": [
   {
    "id": "L3_TIAN",
    "name": "天 · 悬圃",
    "order": 3,
    "content": "木禾、珠树、文玉树、玗琪树、不死树、凤凰鸾鸟、视肉",
    "basis": "《海内西经》「上有木禾，长五寻，大五围」「开明北有视肉、珠树、文玉树、玗琪树、不死树」",
    "level": "A"
   },
   {
    "id": "L2_DU",
    "name": "地 · 帝之下都",
    "order": 2,
    "content": "九井以玉为槛、九门以开明兽守、八隅之岩、赤水之际",
    "basis": "《海内西经》「面有九井，以玉为槛。面有九门，门有开明兽守之，百神之所在」",
    "level": "A"
   },
   {
    "id": "L1_YUAN",
    "name": "渊 · 昆仑南渊",
    "order": 1,
    "content": "深三百仞，为世界的负向极",
    "basis": "《海内西经》「昆仑南渊深三百仞」",
    "level": "A"
   }
  ],
  "waters": [
   {
    "name": "赤水",
    "basis": "《海内西经》「赤水之际」「赤水出……」；《大荒北经》「赤水之北，有章尾山」",
    "level": "A",
    "role": "南界之水，与烛龙所居章尾山相邻"
   },
   {
    "name": "黑水",
    "basis": "《大荒西经》「赤水之后，黑水之前，有大山，名曰昆仑之丘」",
    "level": "A",
    "role": "北界之水，界定昆仑之丘的北缘"
   },
   {
    "name": "弱水",
    "basis": "昆仑神话系统中为环绕之水；《山海经》另处有「弱水」记载，具体段落本作未逐字核对",
    "level": "B",
    "role": "不可渡之水，作为世界外缘"
   },
   {
    "name": "洋水",
    "basis": "《西山经》昆仑之丘条下有其记载；本作未逐字核对全文",
    "level": "B",
    "role": "昆仑东侧水系"
   }
  ],
  "gates": {
   "count": 9,
   "guards": "开明兽，身大类虎而九首，皆人面，东向立昆仑上",
   "basis": "《海内西经》",
   "level": "A",
   "note": "九门的具体方位与形制，文献未载，本作按九宫方位排布，属创作取值"
  },
  "axis": {
   "name": "建木",
   "function": "上下通道，众帝所自上下",
   "basis": "《海内经》建木条；「众帝所自上下」",
   "level": "A",
   "artifacts_binding": "三星堆青铜神树被本作指认为建木的器物化形态",
   "binding_level": "C"
  }
 },
 "deities": [
  {
   "id": "DI",
   "name": "帝",
   "title": "无名之主",
   "depiction": "全篇不给出形象。世界以「帝之下都」的名义成立，帝本身不出场。",
   "basis": "《海内西经》《西山经》皆只称帝之下都",
   "level": "A",
   "worldview_function": "制造「缺席的中心」：所有叙事都朝向一个不出现的位置"
  },
  {
   "id": "LUWU",
   "name": "陆吾",
   "title": "守都之神",
   "depiction": "虎身而九尾，人面而虎爪；司天之九部及帝之囿时",
   "basis": "《西山经》昆仑之丘条",
   "level": "A",
   "role": "守门者，同时掌管天界九部与帝之苑囿的时序"
  },
  {
   "id": "KAIMING",
   "name": "开明兽",
   "title": "九门之守",
   "depiction": "身大类虎而九首，皆人面，东向立昆仑上",
   "basis": "《海内西经》",
   "level": "A",
   "role": "守九门；「东向立」给出固定的朝向，是世界中唯一被明确规定方向的存在"
  },
  {
   "id": "XWWM",
   "name": "西王母",
   "title": "司天之厉及五残",
   "depiction": "其状如人，豹尾虎齿而善啸，蓬发戴胜",
   "basis": "《西山经》「又西北三百五十里，曰玉山，是西王母所居也」；《大荒西经》「有人戴胜、虎齿、有豹尾，穴处，名曰西王母。此山万物尽有」",
   "level": "A",
   "geo_conflict": "《西山经》记其居「玉山」，《大荒西经》则在昆仑之丘条下记其「穴处」。两处文本互异，本作采用「玉山为居所、昆仑之丘为其另有穴处」的双址处理，并明确标注为文本互异而非考订结论",
   "geo_conflict_level": "B",
   "warning": "西王母在后世被塑造为雍容女神，属演变结果。本作只用《山海经》原文形象，不使用后世仙化形象"
  },
  {
   "id": "ZHULONG",
   "name": "烛龙（烛九阴）",
   "title": "昼夜之枢",
   "depiction": "人面蛇身而赤，直目正乘，其瞑乃晦，其视乃明，不食不寝不息，风雨是谒",
   "basis": "《大荒北经》「西北海之外，赤水之北，有章尾山」",
   "level": "A",
   "geo_conflict": "《海外北经》作「钟山」，袁珂校注认为章、钟声近而转。本作以章尾山为准，兼注钟山异名",
   "geo_conflict_level": "B",
   "worldview_function": "世界的时间源：睁眼为昼、闭眼为夜，时间不是钟表而是神的动作"
  },
  {
   "id": "CANCONG",
   "name": "蚕丛",
   "title": "蜀人始祖",
   "depiction": "「其目纵，始称王」",
   "basis": "《华阳国志·蜀志》，成书远晚于三星堆；四川省文物局表述为纵目面具「极可能就是蚕丛的形象」",
   "level": "B",
   "warning": "纵目面具与蚕丛的对应是学界推测，非考古结论。本作以「或」字陈述，不作断言"
  },
  {
   "id": "DALIREN",
   "name": "大立人",
   "title": "无名巫觋",
   "depiction": "青铜大立人，通高约 2.6 米，站立于台座，双手作持物环握状",
   "basis": "三星堆一号祭祀坑出土，实测高度为中国已知最早的真人尺寸青铜人像",
   "level": "A",
   "identity_status": "身份未定：群巫之长、蜀王、主祭者三说并存，学界无定论",
   "identity_level": "B",
   "worldview_function": "世界的执行者：唯一能站着的存在，其余神祇皆为守或为枢"
  }
 ],
 "artifacts": [
  {
   "id": "A01",
   "name": "青铜纵目面具",
   "facts": "高 66 cm、长 138 cm、宽 85 cm、重 71.1 kg；双眼瞳孔呈柱状凸出 16 cm；双耳向两侧充分伸展",
   "facts_basis": "四川省文化和旅游厅公开资料；1986 年二号祭祀坑出土",
   "facts_level": "A",
   "myth_binding": "烛龙「直目正乘」／蚕丛「其目纵」",
   "binding_level": "B",
   "binding_note": "「直目」在郭璞注中释为竖目，与柱状凸目的对应成立与否学界有争议；本作以两说并置，不择一断言",
   "ritual_function": "使人成为神视：戴上面具者获得「视乃明」的能力",
   "ritual_level": "C"
  },
  {
   "id": "A02",
   "name": "青铜神树（一号）",
   "facts": "通高 3.96 m，为已发现最大的青铜树；九枝，每枝端立一鸟；山形底座，龙缘树干而下",
   "facts_basis": "三星堆博物馆公开资料；二号祭祀坑出土",
   "facts_level": "A",
   "myth_binding": "建木（《海内经》）／若木（《大荒北经》）／扶桑（十日所居）三说",
   "binding_level": "B",
   "binding_note": "三说并存的根本原因是：九枝九鸟既可读作九日，也可读作通天层级。本作不作唯一指认",
   "ritual_function": "世界的垂直轴：器物化的通天通道",
   "ritual_level": "C"
  },
  {
   "id": "A03",
   "name": "金杖",
   "facts": "金皮包卷木芯，杖身有鱼、鸟、箭、人面纹饰；一号祭祀坑出土",
   "facts_basis": "三星堆一号祭祀坑出土记录",
   "facts_level": "A",
   "myth_binding": "神权符信：持杖者代表「帝之下都」在人间的话事权",
   "binding_level": "C",
   "ritual_function": "授权之物：杖在谁手，祭仪即由谁主持",
   "ritual_level": "C"
  },
  {
   "id": "A04",
   "name": "玉璋",
   "facts": "大玉璋，长逾 60 cm，歧首刃形；二号祭祀坑出土",
   "facts_basis": "三星堆出土记录",
   "facts_level": "A",
   "myth_binding": "祭山礼器：《周礼》有璋为礼山川之器的记载，三星堆玉璋与此类记载的对应属推测",
   "binding_level": "B",
   "ritual_function": "递交：把人的请求以器物形式交到山川手中",
   "ritual_level": "C"
  },
  {
   "id": "A05",
   "name": "太阳轮形器",
   "facts": "圆形，中心有毂，五道芒条呈放射状；形似方向盘",
   "facts_basis": "三星堆一号祭祀坑出土",
   "facts_level": "A",
   "myth_binding": "太阳符号；具体功能学界有争议，未被确证为某种器具",
   "binding_level": "B",
   "ritual_function": "时间之器：本作将其读作烛龙昼夜之枢的物化，属创作设定",
   "ritual_level": "C"
  },
  {
   "id": "A06",
   "name": "青铜兽面",
   "facts": "兽面形铜饰，双目圆睁、巨口、有角",
   "facts_basis": "三星堆出土记录",
   "facts_level": "A",
   "myth_binding": "本作指认为开明兽／陆吾的器物化形象",
   "binding_level": "C",
   "binding_note": "「九首人面」与兽面形制并不吻合，此对应纯属创作，不得表述为考据结论",
   "ritual_function": "门的看守：把守门者铸在门上",
   "ritual_level": "C"
  }
 ],
 "ritual": {
  "name": "四段祭仪",
  "stages": [
   {
    "id": "R1",
    "name": "启礼",
    "act": "陈器：九门之内依次安放面具、神树、玉璋、金杖",
    "basis_text": "本作设定",
    "level": "C"
   },
   {
    "id": "R2",
    "name": "通神",
    "act": "朝向：面具面东、神树立中、玉璋举向山川",
    "basis_text": "开明兽「东向立」为文献中唯一明确的朝向记载，其余朝向为本作取值",
    "level": "B"
   },
   {
    "id": "R3",
    "name": "献祭",
    "act": "燎、瘗、毁：焚烧、掩埋、砸毁器物",
    "basis_text": "三星堆祭祀坑中观察到的焚烧、砸毁与分层掩埋痕迹",
    "level": "A"
   },
   {
    "id": "R4",
    "name": "成礼",
    "act": "封坑：器物归渊，祭仪结束，世界回到静默",
    "basis_text": "祭祀坑掩埋行为的考古观察",
    "level": "B"
   }
  ],
  "core_conflict": "祭仪的本质是「用掉」而不是「收藏」：三星堆器物大量以破损状态埋藏，说明这套体系的终点是销毁而非陈列。这一点决定了本作的世界观基调是消耗，不是保存。"
 },
 "beasts": [
  {
   "name": "土蝼",
   "depiction": "状如羊而四角，食人",
   "basis": "《西山经》昆仑之丘条",
   "level": "A"
  },
  {
   "name": "钦原",
   "depiction": "状如蜂，大如鸳鸯，蠚鸟兽则死，蠚木则枯",
   "basis": "《西山经》昆仑之丘条",
   "level": "A"
  },
  {
   "name": "凤凰、鸾鸟",
   "depiction": "皆戴蛇践蛇，膺有赤蛇；戴瞂",
   "basis": "《海内西经》开明西、开明北",
   "level": "A"
  },
  {
   "name": "视肉",
   "depiction": "开明北所列异物之一",
   "basis": "《海内西经》",
   "level": "A"
  },
  {
   "name": "圣木曼兑（一曰挺木牙交）",
   "depiction": "开明北所列神木",
   "basis": "《海内西经》",
   "level": "A"
  }
 ],
 "chronology": {
  "separation": "神话时间与考古年代严格分离，不互译。",
  "myth_time": "不设年代。以「帝之下都」为原点，时间由烛龙睁闭眼驱动，属循环而非线性。",
  "archaeo_time": "三星堆遗址约公元前 1600–1000 年；一、二号祭祀坑属商代晚期，1986 年发掘。",
  "text_time": "《山海经》成书于战国至汉，与三星堆存在数百至千余年的时间差。",
  "warning": "三者时间不可通约。任何「山海经记载了三星堆」的说法都不成立——文献晚出于遗址，只能反向推测古蜀观念的残留。本作不采用此说法。"
 },
 "evidence_policy": {
  "A": "文本可逐字援引，或考古实测可查。可作陈述句。",
  "B": "学界推测或有争议，或文本互异。必须用「或」「可能」「学界未定」，不得作断言。",
  "C": "本作创作设定。必须写明「本作设定」，不得表述为考据结论。",
  "forbidden": [
   "把三星堆指认为外星文明",
   "宣称古蜀族源已有定论",
   "宣称《山海经》记载即考古实证",
   "用后世仙化形象（雍容西王母、玉帝王母对偶）覆盖《山海经》原形",
   "把器物与神祇的创作映射写成考古结论"
  ]
 },
 "open_questions": [
  {
   "q": "青铜大立人身份",
   "status": "群巫之长／蜀王／主祭者三说并存，无定论",
   "impact": "决定世界中「执行者」的权属"
  },
  {
   "q": "太阳轮形器功能",
   "status": "学界未确证，太阳符号说为主流但非定论",
   "impact": "本作把它当时间之器，属设定"
  },
  {
   "q": "纵目与「直目」是否同源",
   "status": "柱状凸目与竖目在形态上并不等同，对应成立与否有争议",
   "impact": "这是本作最关键的一条创作假设"
  },
  {
   "q": "神树究竟是建木、若木还是扶桑",
   "status": "三说并存，九枝九鸟可作多解",
   "impact": "决定世界的垂直轴叫什么"
  },
  {
   "q": "西王母双址（玉山／昆仑之丘）",
   "status": "文本互异，非考订问题而是记载差异",
   "impact": "本作采用双址处理，未强行统一"
  },
  {
   "q": "九门九井的具体形制",
   "status": "文献只记数目与材质，无方位与尺寸",
   "impact": "本作的九宫排布全部为创作取值"
  },
  {
   "q": "洋水、黑水同名异述",
   "status": "《海内西经》与《西山经》所记流向相反而不能同时成立，学界与注家未有可依的定说",
   "impact": "决定第二节水系骨架能否给出单一流向；本集因此只取方位对称，不取道里"
  },
  {
   "q": "玉璋未指件",
   "status": "A04 记为器类而非个体，三星堆出土多件玉璋尺寸各异",
   "impact": "评审无法核对具体一件的实测值；须在后续轮次明确到一件个体"
  },
  {
   "q": "青铜兽面无官方条目",
   "status": "仅见发掘研究论文的分类与展陈转述尺寸，未检得四川省文物局藏品条目",
   "impact": "A06 的尺寸只能算展陈口径；或补官方条目，或在正文标为「未检得官方条目」"
  },
  {
   "id": "Q10",
   "q": "钦原「蠚鸟兽则死，蠚木则枯」后句需补核另一来源，方可补入逐字区",
   "status": "resolved_verbatim",
   "resolution": "五份独立来源逐字一致作「蠚鸟兽则死，蠚木则枯」；本集此前误录一处「蠹」已在 R14 改正并留页面校记（#q10-fix）。字形归字，不升格：五源均为整理本/注本电子文本，非一手影印。",
   "resolved_round": 14
  }
 ],
 "narrative_frame": {
  "premise": "帝之下都有九门，门有开明兽守。人能上者极少。三星堆的器物，是那些曾经上去过的人留下的装置。",
  "conflict": "祭仪的终点是销毁。每一次祭祀都在消耗世界的连接点：面具被焚、神树被砸、玉璋被埋。上去的路，每用一次就短一截。",
  "protagonist_position": "主视角不站在神的位置，站在「最后一次祭仪」的执行者位置：他知道这是最后一回，因为器物已经不够再祭一次。",
  "tone": "消耗、克制、不可逆。不写胜利，写交接。"
 },
 "citation_index": {
  "note": "本设定集全部 A 级断言的原文依据。未列入本索引的条目，其依据不是《山海经》原文。",
  "count": 22,
  "chapters_covered": [
   "海内西经",
   "西山经·西次三经",
   "大荒西经",
   "大荒北经"
  ],
  "verification": {
   "method": "逐字比对：每篇以三份以上彼此独立的来源交叉（古籍整理站点原文页 / 学术论文引文 / 公开出版物引文），比对逐字文本而非释义",
   "discrepancies_found": [
    "《西山经》玉山条冠语：通行本作「又西三百五十里」，另有本作「又西北三百五十里」",
    "《海内西经》昆仑之虚句：「方八百里」与「方圆八百里」两种句读"
   ],
   "unresolved": "郭璞注「正乘未闻」，本作照录「未闻」，不补解释",
   "policy": "凡来源间字句有异者记入 variant_note，不擅自择一"
  },
  "pending_level_review": {
   "items": [
    "cosmos.waters.弱水",
    "cosmos.waters.洋水"
   ],
   "reason": "两条原文均已逐字核到：洋水见海内西经「洋水、黑水出西北隅」与西山经「洋水出焉，而西南流注于丑涂之水」；弱水见海内西经「弱水、青水出西南隅」与大荒西经「其下有弱水之渊环之」",
   "current_level": "B",
   "action": "等级本轮未改：改动既有 A/B/C 判定不在自动授权范围，留待单独条目评审"
  },
  "entries": [
   {
    "no": 1,
    "source_id": "SHANHAI_JING",
    "chapter": "海内西经",
    "volume": "卷十一",
    "quote": "海内昆仑之虚，在西北，帝之下都。",
    "supports": "AX-1 帝不显形 / 神系·帝 / cosmos.L2_DU",
    "variant_note": null,
    "level_of_supporting_claims": "A",
    "verbatim_checked": true
   },
   {
    "no": 2,
    "source_id": "SHANHAI_JING",
    "chapter": "海内西经",
    "volume": "卷十一",
    "quote": "昆仑之虚，方八百里，高万仞。",
    "supports": "AX-2 垂直为尊 / cosmos.layers",
    "variant_note": "一作「方圆八百里」，句读差异，义同",
    "level_of_supporting_claims": "A",
    "verbatim_checked": true
   },
   {
    "no": 3,
    "source_id": "SHANHAI_JING",
    "chapter": "海内西经",
    "volume": "卷十一",
    "quote": "上有木禾，长五寻，大五围。",
    "supports": "cosmos.L3_TIAN",
    "variant_note": null,
    "level_of_supporting_claims": "A",
    "verbatim_checked": true
   },
   {
    "no": 4,
    "source_id": "SHANHAI_JING",
    "chapter": "海内西经",
    "volume": "卷十一",
    "quote": "面有九井，以玉为槛。面有九门，门有开明兽守之，百神之所在。",
    "supports": "AX-3 门即权限 / cosmos 九门 / 神系·开明兽",
    "variant_note": null,
    "level_of_supporting_claims": "A",
    "verbatim_checked": true
   },
   {
    "no": 5,
    "source_id": "SHANHAI_JING",
    "chapter": "海内西经",
    "volume": "卷十一",
    "quote": "在八隅之岩，赤水之际，非仁羿莫能上冈之岩。",
    "supports": "AX-3 进入需资格 / cosmos.waters.赤水",
    "variant_note": null,
    "level_of_supporting_claims": "A",
    "verbatim_checked": true
   },
   {
    "no": 6,
    "source_id": "SHANHAI_JING",
    "chapter": "海内西经",
    "volume": "卷十一",
    "quote": "昆仑南渊深三百仞。",
    "supports": "cosmos.L1_YUAN",
    "variant_note": null,
    "level_of_supporting_claims": "A",
    "verbatim_checked": true
   },
   {
    "no": 7,
    "source_id": "SHANHAI_JING",
    "chapter": "海内西经",
    "volume": "卷十一",
    "quote": "开明兽身大类虎而九首，皆人面，东向立昆仑上。",
    "supports": "神系·开明兽 / ritual.R2「东向立」",
    "variant_note": "其余朝向无文献依据，属本作取值",
    "level_of_supporting_claims": "A",
    "verbatim_checked": true
   },
   {
    "no": 8,
    "source_id": "SHANHAI_JING",
    "chapter": "海内西经",
    "volume": "卷十一",
    "quote": "开明西有凤皇、鸾鸟，皆戴蛇践蛇，膺有赤蛇。",
    "supports": "beasts 凤凰、鸾鸟",
    "variant_note": null,
    "level_of_supporting_claims": "A",
    "verbatim_checked": true
   },
   {
    "no": 9,
    "source_id": "SHANHAI_JING",
    "chapter": "海内西经",
    "volume": "卷十一",
    "quote": "开明北有视肉、珠树、文玉树、玗琪树、不死树。……又有离朱、木禾、柏树、甘水、圣木曼兑，一曰挺木牙交。",
    "supports": "beasts 视肉、圣木曼兑",
    "variant_note": "「玗琪」一作「玕琪」；「一曰挺木牙交」为刘歆校定异文",
    "level_of_supporting_claims": "A",
    "verbatim_checked": true
   },
   {
    "no": 10,
    "source_id": "SHANHAI_JING",
    "chapter": "海内西经",
    "volume": "卷十一",
    "quote": "洋水、黑水出西北隅，以东，东行，又东北，南入海，羽民南。",
    "supports": "cosmos.waters.洋水、黑水",
    "variant_note": null,
    "level_of_supporting_claims": "A",
    "verbatim_checked": true
   },
   {
    "no": 11,
    "source_id": "SHANHAI_JING",
    "chapter": "海内西经",
    "volume": "卷十一",
    "quote": "弱水、青水出西南隅，以东，又北，又西南，过毕方鸟东。",
    "supports": "cosmos.waters.弱水",
    "variant_note": null,
    "level_of_supporting_claims": "A",
    "verbatim_checked": true
   },
   {
    "no": 12,
    "source_id": "SHANHAI_JING",
    "chapter": "西山经·西次三经",
    "volume": "卷二",
    "quote": "西南四百里，曰昆仑之丘，是实惟帝之下都，神陆吾司之。其神状虎身而九尾，人面而虎爪；是神也，司天之九部及帝之囿时。",
    "supports": "神系·陆吾 / 帝之下都第二出处",
    "variant_note": null,
    "level_of_supporting_claims": "A",
    "verbatim_checked": true
   },
   {
    "no": 13,
    "source_id": "SHANHAI_JING",
    "chapter": "西山经·西次三经",
    "volume": "卷二",
    "quote": "有兽焉，其状如羊而四角，名曰土蝼，是食人。",
    "supports": "beasts 土蝼",
    "variant_note": null,
    "level_of_supporting_claims": "A",
    "verbatim_checked": true
   },
   {
    "no": 14,
    "source_id": "SHANHAI_JING",
    "chapter": "西山经·西次三经",
    "volume": "卷二",
    "quote": "有鸟焉，其状如蜂，大如鸳鸯，名曰钦原，蠚鸟兽则死，蠚木则枯。",
    "supports": "beasts 钦原",
    "variant_note": "「蠚」一作「蜇」，义同",
    "level_of_supporting_claims": "A",
    "verbatim_checked": true
   },
   {
    "no": 15,
    "source_id": "SHANHAI_JING",
    "chapter": "西山经·西次三经",
    "volume": "卷二",
    "quote": "洋水出焉，而西南流注于丑涂之水。黑水出焉，而西流于大杅。",
    "supports": "cosmos.waters.洋水、黑水第二出处",
    "variant_note": "「丑涂」一作「醜塗」，义同",
    "level_of_supporting_claims": "A",
    "verbatim_checked": true
   },
   {
    "no": 16,
    "source_id": "SHANHAI_JING",
    "chapter": "西山经·西次三经",
    "volume": "卷二",
    "quote": "又西三百五十里，曰玉山，是西王母所居也。西王母其状如人，豹尾虎齿而善啸，蓬发戴胜，是司天之厉及五残。",
    "supports": "神系·西王母 / open_questions 西王母双址之玉山址",
    "variant_note": "一作「又西北三百五十里」；两读并记，不改既有判定",
    "level_of_supporting_claims": "A",
    "verbatim_checked": true
   },
   {
    "no": 17,
    "source_id": "SHANHAI_JING",
    "chapter": "西山经·西次三经",
    "volume": "卷二",
    "quote": "有兽焉，其状如犬而豹文，其角如牛，其名曰狡，其音如吠犬，见则其国大穰。",
    "supports": "beasts 狡",
    "variant_note": "同条另有「胜遇」，本集未单列",
    "level_of_supporting_claims": "A",
    "verbatim_checked": true
   },
   {
    "no": 18,
    "source_id": "SHANHAI_JING",
    "chapter": "大荒西经",
    "volume": "卷十六",
    "quote": "西海之南，流沙之滨，赤水之后，黑水之前，有大山，名曰昆仑之丘。",
    "supports": "cosmos.waters.黑水 / open_questions 西王母双址之昆仑丘址",
    "variant_note": null,
    "level_of_supporting_claims": "A",
    "verbatim_checked": true
   },
   {
    "no": 19,
    "source_id": "SHANHAI_JING",
    "chapter": "大荒西经",
    "volume": "卷十六",
    "quote": "其下有弱水之渊环之，其外有炎火之山，投物辄然。",
    "supports": "cosmos.waters.弱水「环绕之水」读法",
    "variant_note": "此为弱水为环水之唯一原文依据",
    "level_of_supporting_claims": "A",
    "verbatim_checked": true
   },
   {
    "no": 20,
    "source_id": "SHANHAI_JING",
    "chapter": "大荒西经",
    "volume": "卷十六",
    "quote": "有人戴胜，虎齿，有豹尾，穴处，名曰西王母。此山万物尽有。",
    "supports": "神系·西王母（与玉山条并置，不作统一）",
    "variant_note": null,
    "level_of_supporting_claims": "A",
    "verbatim_checked": true
   },
   {
    "no": 21,
    "source_id": "SHANHAI_JING",
    "chapter": "大荒北经",
    "volume": "卷十七",
    "quote": "西北海之外，赤水之北，有章尾山。有神，人面蛇身而赤，直目正乘，其瞑乃晦，其视乃明，不食不寝不息，风雨是谒。是烛九阴，是烛龙。",
    "supports": "神系·烛龙 / cosmos.waters.赤水 / artifacts.A01 直目之文本依据",
    "variant_note": "「身长千里」四字诸本或脱，不影响本条论断",
    "level_of_supporting_claims": "A",
    "verbatim_checked": true
   },
   {
    "no": 22,
    "source_id": "SHANHAI_JING",
    "chapter": "大荒北经·郭璞注",
    "volume": "卷十七",
    "quote": "郭注：直目，目纵也；正乘未闻。",
    "supports": "artifacts.A01 / open_questions 纵目与直目是否同源",
    "variant_note": "郭璞自云「正乘未闻」，本作不强解「正乘」",
    "level_of_supporting_claims": "A",
    "verbatim_checked": true
   }
  ]
 },
 "water_systems_audit": {
  "note": "第二节四水（弱水/洋水/黑水/赤水，附青水）的原文对账。原文与 citation_index 同源，逐字可对。",
  "entries": [
   {
    "water": "弱水",
    "chapter": "海内西经·卷十一",
    "quote": "弱水、青水出西南隅，以东，又北，又西南，过毕方鸟东。",
    "nature": "出水方位＋流向",
    "role_in_book": "四水之一，与青水同出"
   },
   {
    "water": "弱水",
    "chapter": "大荒西经·卷十六",
    "quote": "其下有弱水之渊环之，其外有炎火之山，投物辄然。",
    "nature": "空间关系（渊环昆仑之丘）",
    "role_in_book": "「环绕之水」读法的唯一原文依据"
   },
   {
    "water": "洋水",
    "chapter": "海内西经·卷十一",
    "quote": "洋水、黑水出西北隅，以东，东行，又东北，南入海，羽民南。",
    "nature": "出水方位＋流向",
    "role_in_book": "四水之一"
   },
   {
    "water": "洋水",
    "chapter": "西山经·西次三经·卷二",
    "quote": "洋水出焉，而西南流注于丑涂之水。",
    "nature": "流向（西南流，注丑涂之水）",
    "role_in_book": "第二条记载"
   },
   {
    "water": "黑水",
    "chapter": "海内西经·卷十一",
    "quote": "洋水、黑水出西北隅，以东，东行，又东北，南入海，羽民南。",
    "nature": "出水方位＋流向（与洋水同句）",
    "role_in_book": "四水之一，作北缘"
   },
   {
    "water": "黑水",
    "chapter": "西山经·西次三经·卷二",
    "quote": "黑水出焉，而西流于大杅。",
    "nature": "流向（西流于大杅，无入海）",
    "role_in_book": "第二条记载"
   },
   {
    "water": "赤水",
    "chapter": "海内西经·卷十一",
    "quote": "在八隅之岩，赤水之际，非仁羿莫能上冈之岩。",
    "nature": "方位界标（赤水之「际」）",
    "role_in_book": "南界之水；进入资格的界标"
   },
   {
    "water": "赤水",
    "chapter": "大荒西经·卷十六",
    "quote": "西海之南，流沙之滨，赤水之后，黑水之前，有大山，名曰昆仑之丘。",
    "nature": "方位界标（赤水之后）",
    "role_in_book": "界定昆仑之丘南缘"
   },
   {
    "water": "赤水",
    "chapter": "大荒北经·卷十七",
    "quote": "西北海之外，赤水之北，有章尾山。",
    "nature": "方位界标（赤水之北）",
    "role_in_book": "烛龙所居章尾山的定位"
   },
   {
    "water": "青水",
    "chapter": "海内西经·卷十一",
    "quote": "弱水、青水出西南隅，以东，又北，又西南，过毕方鸟东。",
    "nature": "出水方位＋流向（与弱水同句）",
    "role_in_book": "四水的补充项，原文仅此一处"
   }
  ],
  "discrepancies": [
   {
    "topic": "洋水两说",
    "detail": "《海内西经》作「出西北隅……又东北，南入海」；《西山经》作「西南流注于丑涂之水」。方向相反，终点不同，两条不能同时成立",
    "policy": "同名异述，不选边、不合并，留 open_questions"
   },
   {
    "topic": "黑水两说",
    "detail": "《海内西经》与洋水同句作「出西北隅……南入海」；《西山经》作「西流于大杅」且不提入海",
    "policy": "同上"
   }
  ],
  "taken_skeleton": [
   "以昆仑为心，西南隅出弱水与青水、西北隅出洋水与黑水——按《海内西经》同句方位取，不外推道里",
   "赤水作外围界标而非水路：三处均以赤水为方位基准（际/后/北）",
   "弱水之「环」仅取《大荒西经》一条，不作通说"
  ],
  "not_done": [
   "不把四水对应到今天的任何一条河（弱水、黑水今地众说无定论）",
   "不把两处流向差异解释为传抄错误（缺版本证据）"
  ],
  "level_note": "弱水、洋水等级仍为 B 未改：改动既有判定不在自动授权范围。赤水、黑水保持原等级不变。"
 },
 "artifact_source_index": {
  "note": "六件器物 A 级事实的来源索引。原则：能挂到官方页面的挂官方页面，官媒报道作补充；同一数值来源不一致时两边并列，不取平均、不择一。等级一律不动。",
  "items": [
   {
    "id": "A01",
    "name": "青铜纵目面具",
    "verified": [
     "商代；1986 年二号祭祀坑出土，同坑三件，分大小两型",
     "高 66 cm；一侧 138 cm；瞳孔柱状凸出 16 cm、直径 13.5 cm",
     "馆藏三星堆博物馆，一级文物"
    ],
    "sources": [
     {
      "name": "四川省文物局·青铜纵目面具藏品条目",
      "url": "https://wwj.sc.gov.cn/scwwj/sdai/2023/4/25/11995271d8f5407b88a965b38e4a3fbd.shtml",
      "published": "2023-04-25"
     },
     {
      "name": "四川省文化和旅游厅《三星堆：未知的世界最令人着迷》",
      "url": "http://wlt.sc.gov.cn/scwlt/hydt/2021/3/30/08abf38e28874d469fc17b4c203d775d.shtml",
      "published": "2021-03-30"
     },
     {
      "name": "四川广播电视台《“堆”点知识丨三星堆的1986》",
      "url": "https://www.sctv.com/news/2087354990372315138",
      "published": "2026-08-12"
     }
    ],
    "variants": [
     "138 cm 这一边：文物局作「宽」，文旅厅作「长」；文旅厅另给「宽 85」，与文物局的「宽 138」互斥",
     "重量：71.1 公斤（文旅厅）vs 逾 80 公斤（四川广电）"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "A02",
    "name": "青铜神树（一号）",
    "verified": [
     "1986 年二号祭祀坑出土",
     "由 200 余块残件修复，修复后通高 3.96 m，为迄今最大单件青铜器",
     "顶部残缺，原高估计接近 5 m"
    ],
    "sources": [
     {
      "name": "川观新闻《三星堆青铜神树：古蜀人的“通天梦”》",
      "url": "https://cbgc.scol.com.cn/news/6731241",
      "published": "2025-09-12"
     },
     {
      "name": "中国新闻网《余健：三星堆的青铜神树为何还在不断“长高”》",
      "url": "https://m.chinanews.com/wap/detail/cht/zw/10255975.shtml",
      "published": "2024-07-23"
     },
     {
      "name": "央视新闻《文博日历丨沉睡三千年 一醒惊天下》",
      "url": "https://content-static.cctvnews.cctv.com/snow-book/index.html?item_id=6472754750158694574",
      "published": "2023-03-24"
     },
     {
      "name": "四川省情网《青铜神树：藏有多少未解之谜》",
      "url": "http://scdfz.sc.gov.cn/scyx/scfw/content_9817",
      "published": "2018-09-09"
     }
    ],
    "variants": [
     "「九枝九鸟」齐全度不一：导览类来源写「九只、其一缺失」，官方修复叙述不提缺失",
     "3.96 m 为修复后高度，非原器高度，引用须带「修复后」限定"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "A03",
    "name": "金杖",
    "verified": [
     "商代；1986 年一号祭祀坑出土；金皮包卷木芯，芯已炭化",
     "文物局条目：全长 142、宽 4、高 2、直径 2.3 cm，一级",
     "一端平雕三组图案约 46 cm：人头（五齿高冠）、鸟与鱼、箭翎"
    ],
    "sources": [
     {
      "name": "四川省文物局·金杖藏品条目",
      "url": "https://wwj.sc.gov.cn/scwwj/sdai/2021/9/10/a4b25c16bdf34ca4bb58365a5e7d0d9d.shtml",
      "published": "2021-09-10"
     },
     {
      "name": "四川省文物局《顶流来了！三星堆博物馆登陆〈国家宝藏3〉》",
      "url": "https://wwj.sc.gov.cn/scwwj/mtgz/2020/11/9/e2243c8bfd644bd39c7890a8cc337786.shtml",
      "published": "2020-11-09"
     },
     {
      "name": "央视新闻《文博日历丨不想当金箍棒的金腰带不是好金杖》",
      "url": "https://content-static.cctvnews.cctv.com/snow-book/index.html?item_id=8679751370777124364",
      "published": "2024-08-24"
     },
     {
      "name": "三星堆博物馆微博（金杖通长 142cm、厚约 0.2mm、重约 500g）",
      "url": "https://m.weibo.cn/detail/5347811027584275",
      "published": "2026-09-27"
     }
    ],
    "variants": [
     "长度 142 cm（文物局）与 1.43 m（央视）差 1 cm，属换算进位，非矛盾",
     "厚度约 0.2 mm 与整杖约 500 g 仅见博物馆微博，官方条目未记重量，本集不采用"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "A04",
    "name": "玉璋",
    "verified": [
     "三星堆出土多件，尺寸不一",
     "文物局两条条目分别记长 91.1/宽 12.1/厚 0.62，与长 38.3/宽 8.1/厚 0.82",
     "最大玉牙璋：通长 90.8/宽 7.8（文物局）与长 92/厚 6 mm（人民日报）两说"
    ],
    "sources": [
     {
      "name": "四川省文物局·玉璋藏品条目（长 91.1cm）",
      "url": "https://wwj.sc.gov.cn/scwwj/sdai/2021/9/10/cb4becd5808645319011f537ac057862.shtml",
      "published": "2021-09-10"
     },
     {
      "name": "四川省文物局·玉璋藏品条目（长 38.3cm）",
      "url": "https://wwj.sc.gov.cn/scwwj/sdai/2021/9/10/20e996373e5248e0a7f4d5cd5799af0f.shtml",
      "published": "2021-09-10"
     },
     {
      "name": "四川省文物局《不止神秘，三星堆》（玉牙璋通长 90.8）",
      "url": "https://wwj.sc.gov.cn/scwwj/wbyw/2020/5/19/0554a21df8ec414ab71dbd0bf0803c55.shtml",
      "published": "2020-05-19"
     },
     {
      "name": "人民日报《三星堆博物馆 述说瑰丽的古蜀文明》（长 92cm、厚 6mm）",
      "url": "http://paper.people.com.cn/rmrbhwb/page/2018-07/31/07/rmrbhwb2018073107.pdf",
      "published": "2018-07-31"
     }
    ],
    "variants": [
     "同一件最大牙璋长度 90.8 / 91.1 / 92 cm 出自三源，差值在测量与进位范围内"
    ],
    "gap": "本集 A04 只写「三星堆出土记录」，未指认具体一件；提器类而不指件，评审无从核对",
    "specimen_options": {
     "round_added": 15,
     "page_anchor": "#a04-specimen",
     "previous_framing": "把 90.8 / 91.1 / 92 cm 当作同一件的三个测量值",
     "corrected_framing": "数值差不是测量口径，而是两件不同的大牙璋；92 cm 为央媒转述",
     "candidates": [
      {
       "which": "有官方登记页的大牙璋",
       "source": "四川省文物局藏品条目 2021-09-10",
       "size": "长91.1cm × 宽12.1cm × 厚0.62cm",
       "material": "蚀变白云岩黑色，邸部火烧后呈浅青黄",
       "grade": "A"
      },
      {
       "which": "称为三星堆最大牙璋的那件",
       "source": "四川省文旅局宣传文 2020-05-19",
       "size": "通长90.8cm × 宽7.8cm × 厚0.6cm",
       "grade": "B"
      },
      {
       "which": "央媒称商代最大玉牙璋",
       "source": "人民网 2018-07-31",
       "size": "长92cm × 厚6mm",
       "grade": "B"
      },
      {
       "which": "另一件：K2③:201-4 线刻祭山图边璋",
       "source": "川研院《三星堆古蜀王国的山崇拜》",
       "size": "通长54.2cm × 射宽8.8 × 邸长11.4 × 厚0.8",
       "note": "两面线刻相同祭山图，分上下两幅，中间云雷纹",
       "grade": "A"
      }
     ],
     "why_not_one_piece": "91.1宽12.1 与 90.8宽7.8 的宽度差近4.3cm，远超进位误差，不能用测量口径解释",
     "two_cases_for_shot": {
      "case_a_has_engraving": "选 K2③:201-4（54.2cm）：镜头里有线刻可拍；代价是它不是最大件",
      "case_b_largest": "选 90.8/91.1/92 近一米大牙璋：体量最大；代价是宽7.8 vs 12.1 口径差本集无法消解，画面只能写长近一米"
     },
     "unchanged": "A04 在第十四节的落位（祭仪·献璋·交器之手）与 A04 形制 A 判定均不改；选件属评审/主作品导演决定"
    }
   },
   {
    "id": "A05",
    "name": "太阳形器",
    "verified": [
     "商代；出土时全部砸碎并经火焚烧，可辨六个个体，复原两件",
     "直径均约 85 cm；阳部直径 28、高 6 cm；五芒放射、外圈相连，二次铸造"
    ],
    "sources": [
     {
      "name": "四川省文物局·商铜太阳形器藏品条目",
      "url": "https://wwj.sc.gov.cn/scwwj/sdai/2021/7/9/362e186e2f624c958081fc6c8b7cb3ca.shtml",
      "published": "2021-07-09"
     },
     {
      "name": "四川省文化和旅游厅《三星堆：未知的世界最令人着迷》",
      "url": "http://wlt.sc.gov.cn/scwlt/hydt/2021/3/30/08abf38e28874d469fc17b4c203d775d.shtml",
      "published": "2021-03-30"
     },
     {
      "name": "央视新闻《文博日历丨这个“太阳”，好像个方向盘啊》",
      "url": "https://content-static.cctvnews.cctv.com/snow-book/index.html?item_id=3830296706345410927",
      "published": "2024-09-07"
     },
     {
      "name": "四川广播电视台《“堆”点知识丨三星堆的1986》",
      "url": "https://www.sctv.com/news/2087354990372315138",
      "published": "2026-08-12"
     }
    ],
    "variants": [
     "坑位两说：文旅厅系于 2 号坑；四川广电写在「一号坑」段；文物局条目未标坑"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "A06",
    "name": "青铜兽面",
    "verified": [
     "二号坑出土；薄片浅浮雕面具类",
     "按形态分三型，每型 3 件，共 9 件（发掘研究论文分类）"
    ],
    "sources": [
     {
      "name": "四川省文物考古研究院《三星堆出土青铜雕像与面具研究》",
      "url": "https://www.sckg.com/uploads/soft/20230509/2-23050916064D27.pdf",
      "published": ""
     },
     {
      "name": "四川省文物考古研究院《广汉三星堆遗址二号祭祀坑发掘简报》",
      "url": "https://www.sckg.com/uploads/soft/20230509/2-230509155201302.pdf",
      "published": ""
     }
    ],
    "variants": [
     "个体尺寸宽 27.7／高 12.7／厚 0.2 cm 仅见展陈条目转述，属「展陈口径」非「考古实测口径」"
    ],
    "gap": "未检得四川省文物局官方藏品条目——六件中唯一只有二级转述的一件"
   }
  ],
  "cross_source_conflicts": 4,
  "conflicts_list": [
   "纵目面具 138 cm 的轴名（宽/长）与「宽 85」互斥",
   "纵目面具重量 71.1 kg vs 逾 80 kg",
   "太阳形器坑位 2 号坑 vs 1 号坑",
   "玉牙璋长度 90.8 / 91.1 / 92 cm"
  ],
  "untouched": "第三节器物谱的表述与六件的 A/B/C 等级全部未改；本轮仅新增索引与校记"
 },
 "beast_index": {
  "section": "十三、昆仑异兽谱",
  "count": 8,
  "grade_policy": "八条引文均逐字核到 ≥2 独立来源，故引文一律 A 级；「引文为 A 级」不等于「本集必收」，收与不收分开标",
  "items": [
   {
    "name": "陆吾",
    "src": "山海经·西山经（西次三经·昆仑之丘）",
    "quote": "西南四百里，曰昆仑之丘，是实惟帝之下都，神陆吾司之。其神状虎身而九尾，人面而虎爪；是神也，司天之九部及帝之囿时。",
    "grade": "A",
    "sources": [
     "古文岛·西山经原文",
     "抖音百科·西山经原文",
     "深圳特区报《山海百灵》引西次三经",
     "国学大师·郭璞注本"
    ],
    "variant": "郭璞注「即肩吾也。庄周曰：肩吾得之以处大山也」，注家视为同一；本集只记注不改神格",
    "usage": "写作「九门之内的最高司守」，并明示其职守为帝之下都司守者兼司天之九部，不是门吏"
   },
   {
    "name": "土蝼",
    "src": "山海经·西山经（同段·昆仑之丘）",
    "quote": "有兽焉，其状如羊而四角，名曰土蝼，是食人。",
    "grade": "A",
    "sources": [
     "古文岛",
     "抖音百科（同段两源一致）"
    ],
    "variant": "无文字异文",
    "usage": "仅用于「山的危险性」一句；神圣与危险同条并列是原文结构"
   },
   {
    "name": "钦原",
    "src": "山海经·西山经（同段·昆仑之丘，鸟）",
    "quote": "有鸟焉，其状如蜂，大如鸳鸯，名曰钦原。",
    "grade": "A",
    "sources": [
     "古文岛",
     "抖音百科（同段一致）"
    ],
    "variant": "后句「蠚鸟兽则死，蠚木则枯」两源均截断，未纳入逐字区，待下一轮补核",
    "usage": "未采用作画面：体型与形貌互相抵消，落图会变成怪物设计"
   },
   {
    "name": "开明兽",
    "src": "山海经·海内西经",
    "quote": "面有九门，门有开明兽守之，百神之所在。…开明兽身大类虎而九首，皆人面，东向立昆仑上。",
    "grade": "A",
    "sources": [
     "古文岛",
     "抖音百科",
     "河南牧业经济学院《山海经》无注释版",
     "汉典·开明兽",
     "5000言"
    ],
    "variant": "断句异文：识典古籍《山海经笺疏》作「昆仑南，渊深三百仞」，主流本作「昆仑南渊深三百仞」；本集取主流",
    "usage": "第九节九门之守只取「门有开明兽守之」，九首不作画面依据（原文重点是「东向立」）"
   },
   {
    "name": "夔",
    "src": "山海经·大荒东经（流波山）",
    "quote": "东海中有流波山，入海七千里。其上有兽，状如牛，苍身而无角，一足，出入水则必风雨，其光如日月，其声如雷，其名曰夔。黄帝得之，以其皮为鼓，橛以雷兽之骨，声闻五百里，以威天下。",
    "grade": "A",
    "sources": [
     "古文岛",
     "抖音百科",
     "重庆三峡学院《夔州文化论纲》",
     "人民网《青铜器上铸造夔纹》",
     "QQ阅读《国学句典》"
    ],
    "variant": "「雷兽」同段另指一物，与夔非同一，本集不并",
    "usage": "只取一足·苍身无角·风雨·雷声四形，不取「黄帝得之」的收编叙事"
   },
   {
    "name": "九尾狐",
    "src": "山海经·南山经（青丘之山）＋大荒东经（青丘之国）",
    "quote": "（南山经）有兽焉，其状如狐而九尾，其音如婴儿，能食人；食者不蛊。｜（大荒东经）有青丘之国，有狐九尾。",
    "grade": "A",
    "sources": [
     "古文岛",
     "超星古籍PDF",
     "澎湃引文",
     "Project Gutenberg 繁体本",
     "抖音百科（大荒东经）",
     "纪妖/知妖",
     "《山海经校注》"
    ],
    "variant": "衍文：抖音百科南山经版作「其状如狐而背生九尾」，多「背生」二字；两副面孔：南山经「能食人」vs 大荒东经郭璞注「太平则出而为瑞也」，按同名异述并列不合并",
    "usage": "置于「山外之兽」，不入九门，不作祥瑞符号；两说俱留"
   },
   {
    "name": "狌狌",
    "src": "山海经·南山经（招摇之山）",
    "quote": "有兽焉，其状如禺而白耳，伏行人走，其名曰狌狌，食之善走。",
    "grade": "A",
    "sources": [
     "古文岛",
     "抖音百科·狌狌",
     "国学导航·南山经",
     "识典古籍·郭璞传本"
    ],
    "variant": "「禺」为猿类泛称非具体种属；「食之善走」为效用记述，本集不作药效引用",
    "usage": "只用「伏行人走」这一可被镜头直接拍到的动作"
   },
   {
    "name": "狡",
    "src": "山海经·西山经（玉山）",
    "quote": "有兽焉，其状如犬而豹文，其角如牛，其名曰狡，其音如吠犬，见则其国大穰。",
    "grade": "A",
    "sources": [
     "古文岛",
     "抖音百科",
     "沪江《山海经图鉴·狡》"
    ],
    "variant": "「大穰」一作「大稔」，义同",
    "usage": "明确不采用：属占验兽，落点在国不在山；列出以示「查到且说明为何不收」"
   }
  ],
  "not_adopted": [
   "钦原",
   "狡"
  ],
  "open_notes": [
   "钦原后句「蠚鸟兽则死，蠚木则枯」待补核",
   "九尾狐「能食人 / 为瑞」两说未择一",
   "本集不为异兽新增图像设定"
  ],
  "untouched": "第六至九节既有表述与全部 A/B/C 判定未改；九门命名（S5）未预设"
 },
 "artifact_landing": {
  "section": "十四、器物落点表",
  "count": 6,
  "source_section": "十二、器物来源索引（形制数字全部可回查）",
  "structure_basis": "二层「地·帝之下都」＋五节祭仪四段（启礼/通神/献祭/成礼）＋叙事框架「最后一次祭仪」",
  "placement_policy": "落点一律为创作取值 C（三星堆未留下祭仪空间布置记录）；形制为 A；神格绑定沿用第四节既有等级，不重定",
  "items": [
   {
    "artifact_id": "A01",
    "name": "青铜纵目面具",
    "scene": "地 · 帝之下都，祭台前区",
    "shot": "启礼段第一镜：戴具者侧逆光中近景，双目柱体入画；随后切正面半身",
    "take": "高66/宽85/长138 三轴比例、瞳孔柱状凸出16cm、双耳向两侧伸展（前两项定轮廓，第三项定侧面剪影）",
    "skip": "不把「纵目即直目」当作断言入画（B级、学界有争议）；面具只作器物不作神格图解，亦不与烛龙「直目」同框",
    "basis": {
     "form": "A",
     "myth_binding": "B",
     "placement": "C"
    }
   },
   {
    "artifact_id": "A02",
    "name": "青铜神树（一号）",
    "scene": "地 · 帝之下都，中轴",
    "shot": "通神段主镜：以树为画面竖轴，仰角起、缓推至九枝端鸟，人处在树下三分之一处",
    "take": "通高3.96m竖向尺度、九枝、每枝端立一鸟、山形底座、龙缘树干而下（九枝九鸟只作层级重复节律）",
    "skip": "不指认建木/若木/扶桑三说之一；龙缘树干只给一段不完整缠绕，不给可读整条龙形",
    "basis": {
     "form": "A",
     "myth_binding": "B",
     "placement": "C"
    }
   },
   {
    "artifact_id": "A03",
    "name": "金杖",
    "scene": "祭仪 · 通神与献祭之间的交接点",
    "shot": "特写起手：一手握杖中段，金皮反光先入画；纹饰（鱼/鸟/箭/人面）一次横移扫过，不逐纹停格",
    "take": "金皮包卷木芯的「非实心」质感、杖身纹饰带、直径2.3cm（画面里能被一只手完全握拢）",
    "skip": "不在1.42m与1.43m之间择一（并列，差1cm属进位差）；不给「王者持杖」的加冕姿态——杖的意义是谁主持而非谁拥有",
    "basis": {
     "form": "A",
     "myth_binding": "C",
     "placement": "C"
    }
   },
   {
    "artifact_id": "A04",
    "name": "玉璋",
    "scene": "祭仪 · 献祭段，交器之手",
    "shot": "俯拍两手竖持，歧首朝上出画外；随后器物离手落地一瞬，不给落点特写",
    "take": "歧首刃形与大玉璋尺度（长逾60cm）决定手与器比例；玉色取「火烧后浅青黄」的出土状态，不取新玉的白",
    "skip": "不指认具体个体（90.8/91.1/92cm 三说未定且分属不同个体）；不把《周礼》璋礼山川的记载画成仪式图解",
    "basis": {
     "form": "A",
     "myth_binding": "B",
     "placement": "C"
    }
   },
   {
    "artifact_id": "A05",
    "name": "太阳形器（铜太阳形器）",
    "scene": "地 · 帝之下都，地面与光影",
    "shot": "成礼段：不给人，只给器物投在地面的芒条影，镜头落在影上；器物本体只在画面上缘露一半",
    "take": "阳部直径28cm、五芒、外圈直径85cm、芒条与外围相连、阳部中心及晕圈共五个圆孔（用作地面投影的时间刻度）",
    "skip": "不把功能当结论（学界未确证）；不写「六个体复原两件」为画面依据，画面里只出现一件",
    "basis": {
     "form": "A",
     "myth_binding": "C",
     "placement": "C",
     "note": "功能未定，只作创作读法"
    }
   },
   {
    "artifact_id": "A06",
    "name": "青铜兽面",
    "scene": "九门 · 门枢",
    "shot": "门开合的一刻，兽面被门缝扫过；两次开合之间露两次，每次不足一秒",
    "take": "双目圆睁、巨口、有角、阔口露齿四项形制特征；27.7×12.7/厚0.2cm 决定它是一枚「贴在门上的薄片」而非独立雕塑",
    "skip": "不据此断言它是开明兽或陆吾的器物化形象（九首人面与兽面不吻合，此说纯属创作）；不给正面停格，停了就变成图腾",
    "basis": {
     "form": "A",
     "myth_binding": "C",
     "placement": "C"
    }
   }
  ],
  "discipline": [
   "一件器物只给一个主落点，避免六件堆在中轴互相稀释",
   "每个落点须能反推回第十二节核源（66/85/138、3.96m、2.3cm、28/85cm、27.7×12.7）",
   "落点可自定，数字不可改"
  ],
  "untouched": "第四节器物谱、第十二节来源索引与全部 A/B/C 判定未改；未写入主作品文件"
 },
 "gate_index": {
  "section": "十五、九门与方位",
  "count": 9,
  "source_quote": "面有九井，以玉为槛；面有九门，门有开明兽守之，百神之所在。（《山海经·海内西经》）",
  "quote_sources": [
   "抖音百科《山海经·海内西经》原文条（2023-09-20）",
   "光明日报 2025-07-21《「昆仑石刻」与不死药》",
   "国家人文历史 2025-11-05 引文"
  ],
  "quote_grade": "A（三源逐字一致）",
  "reading_variants": [
   "每面九门（四面共三十六门；抖音百科「仙境」义项同此）",
   "四面共九门（原文未明示四面）"
  ],
  "our_choice": "取九座主门＝四面对位八门＋中轴一门，属简化取舍，标 C，非考据复原",
  "rejected_derivative": "部分转述本于「门有开明兽守之」后增「皆东向立」，三核源同段引文均无此四字，不采，仅作校记",
  "items": [
   {
    "gate_id": "G01",
    "name": "启明门",
    "ordinal": "第一门",
    "bearing": "东面 · 第一门（日出之位，启礼由此入）",
    "guard_artifact_taboo": "守开明兽（原文唯一守者）；器纵目面具 A01",
    "taboo": "空手入门；入门不语",
    "basis": "门名 C · 方位 C · 守者分配 C · 器 C（A01 形制 A）"
   },
   {
    "gate_id": "G02",
    "name": "朝晖门",
    "ordinal": "第二门",
    "bearing": "东面 · 第二门（白日之位）",
    "guard_artifact_taboo": "守开明兽；器玉璋 A04（受而不献）",
    "taboo": "器不入此门；持器者不越门限",
    "basis": "门名 C · 方位 C · 守者分配 C · 器 C（A04 形制 A）"
   },
   {
    "gate_id": "G03",
    "name": "赤水门",
    "ordinal": "第三门",
    "bearing": "南面 · 第一门（赤水之际，《海内西经》「在八隅之岩，赤水之际」）",
    "guard_artifact_taboo": "守开明兽；器太阳形器 A05（只留芒影）",
    "taboo": "不在南面立灯烛；不以影为门",
    "basis": "门名取本页「赤水」C · 原文赤水方位 B · 守/器 C"
   },
   {
    "gate_id": "G04",
    "name": "炎火门",
    "ordinal": "第四门",
    "bearing": "南面 · 第二门（外有炎火之山，《大荒西经》「投物辄然」）",
    "guard_artifact_taboo": "守开明兽；不设常器——此门无器，只有一道门槛",
    "taboo": "投物入门（投物辄然）；携火入内",
    "basis": "门名取「炎火之山」C · 原文 A · 「此门无器」为本作取舍 C"
   },
   {
    "gate_id": "G05",
    "name": "弱水门",
    "ordinal": "第五门",
    "bearing": "西面 · 第一门（其下有弱水之渊环之，《大荒西经》）",
    "guard_artifact_taboo": "守开明兽；器金杖 A03（西面主交接）",
    "taboo": "涉水入门；以杖指门",
    "basis": "门名取「弱水」C · 原文弱水之渊 A/B · 守/器 C"
   },
   {
    "gate_id": "G06",
    "name": "玄圃门",
    "ordinal": "第六门",
    "bearing": "西面 · 第二门（悬圃之位，二层「天·悬圃」下接之口）",
    "guard_artifact_taboo": "守开明兽；器青铜兽面 A06（贴门枢）",
    "taboo": "正面停视门枢；以兽面为独立造像",
    "basis": "门名取「悬圃」C · 方位 C · 守/器 C（A06 形制 A）"
   },
   {
    "gate_id": "G07",
    "name": "幽都门",
    "ordinal": "第七门",
    "bearing": "北面 · 第一门（北为幽暗之位，二层「渊·昆仑南渊」与此门相对）",
    "guard_artifact_taboo": "守开明兽；不设明器——北面只留九井之一在门内",
    "taboo": "向北举火；在幽都门内计数",
    "basis": "门名 C · 方位 C · 守/器 C"
   },
   {
    "gate_id": "G08",
    "name": "烛龙门",
    "ordinal": "第八门",
    "bearing": "北面 · 第二门（烛龙所居章尾山，《大荒北经》「西北海之外，赤水之北」）",
    "guard_artifact_taboo": "守开明兽；无器，只留「直目」一瞥",
    "taboo": "以烛龙为门神；直视其目",
    "basis": "门名取「烛龙」C · 方位有原文依据 A · 守/器 C"
   },
   {
    "gate_id": "G09",
    "name": "建木门",
    "ordinal": "第九门",
    "bearing": "中轴 · 唯一一门（九井以玉为槛，神树占中轴竖轴）",
    "guard_artifact_taboo": "守开明兽（中轴门为其本位）；器青铜神树 A02",
    "taboo": "绕轴而行；伐枝取鸟",
    "basis": "门名取「建木」三说之一 C（三说未定不择一）· 原文九井玉槛 A · 守/器 C"
   }
  ],
  "invented_scope": "门名 9 / 方位分配 9 / 器物分配 9 / 禁忌 9 —— 全部 C；原文只给「九门、九井以玉为槛、门有开明兽守之、百神之所在」",
  "naming_policy": "九门名一律取本页已有概念（启礼/赤水/炎火/弱水/悬圃/幽都/烛龙/建木/开明），不另引外部典籍，避免多一层无法核的出处",
  "untouched": "第八节「九门九井形制」未解问题保留未动；九门命名不写入 A 级；未触碰主作品文件"
 },
 "machine_readable": {
  "llms_txt": "https://www.huodouai.com/aholo/kunlun-worldview-llms.txt",
  "json": "https://www.huodouai.com/aholo/kunlun-worldview-v1.json",
  "lock_receipts": "https://www.huodouai.com/aholo/worldview-evolution/lock/LOCK-RECEIPTS.json",
  "jsonld": "页面 head 内嵌 schema.org CreativeWork + Dataset 两段",
  "grading_note": "A 级须逐字复核并给核源；B 级为有争议或单源；C 级为本作设定；引文级别≠采用决定",
  "readonly": "只读静态文件，不含令牌或个人数据",
  "section": "页脚前「机器可读入口」卡"
 },
 "judge_guide": {
  "section": "#guide",
  "purpose": "给第一次打开页面的评审三分钟内判断本设定值不值得信：读什么、主张是什么、哪里明确不确定",
  "reading_path": [
   {
    "step": 1,
    "anchor": "#sec3",
    "what": "神系与权力结构"
   },
   {
    "step": 2,
    "anchor": "#sec14",
    "what": "器物落点表：六件器物在画面中的位置与镜头"
   },
   {
    "step": 3,
    "anchor": "#sec10",
    "what": "引文索引：逐字出处与可打开链接"
   },
   {
    "step": 4,
    "anchor": "#sec8",
    "what": "十处未解问题"
   }
  ],
  "claims": [
   {
    "no": 1,
    "claim": "分工而非互证：三源各守一层，不拿一方证明另一方",
    "ref": "#sec1"
   },
   {
    "no": 2,
    "claim": "器物是神在人间的执行装置",
    "ref": "#sec14"
   },
   {
    "no": 3,
    "claim": "每个数字都要能回溯到第十二节来源行",
    "ref": "#sec12"
   }
  ],
  "declared_uncertainties": [
   {
    "no": 1,
    "item": "洋水/黑水两经流向相反，判同名异述不选边",
    "ref": "#sec11"
   },
   {
    "no": 2,
    "item": "「面有九门」两读并列不选边",
    "ref": "#sec15"
   },
   {
    "no": 3,
    "item": "九个门名全为 C，无原文可回溯",
    "ref": "#sec15"
   }
  ],
  "what_this_page_does_not_do": [
   "不做器物与文献的一对一指认（形制数字除外）",
   "不改既有 A/B/C 判定",
   "不触碰主作品《昆仑下都·古蜀神祀》的任何文件"
  ],
  "grading_legend": {
   "A": "可逐字复核",
   "B": "有争议、带争议点",
   "C": "本作设定"
  },
  "note": "引文级别不等于采用决定：A 级引文也可能被本集舍去"
 },
 "citation_audit_log": {
  "rounds": [
   {
    "round": 14,
    "scope": "钦原后句字形（Q10）",
    "finding": "「蠹木则枯」为形近讹字，原文作「蠚木则枯」",
    "sources": [
     "郭璞注本《山海经》卷二（国学大师影印本，fanti/512h/5621）",
     "识典古籍《山水二经合刻》（北魏郦道元注本，book/HY2543/chapter/1kpc18irvg9os）",
     "古文岛《西山经第二》（m.gushiwen.cn/guwen/bookv_f47f41623f88.aspx）",
     "抖音百科《山海经·西山经》原文条（m.baike.com/wiki/…19887540）",
     "QQ阅读《西次三经》（m.inf.qq.com/read/1000846254/11）"
    ],
    "decision": "按五源改正，并在页面留校记，不静默修订；等级不动",
    "page_anchor": "#q10-fix"
   },
   {
    "round": 15,
    "scope": "A04 玉璋「三说」误判为同一件的测量值，实为两件不同大牙璋",
    "finding": "此前一行写 90.8/91.1/92 cm 像同一器物三个测量值；逐源打开后：91.1宽12.1（文物局藏品条目，A级）与90.8宽7.8（文旅局，B级）宽度差4.3cm，不能用进位解释；另有 K2③:201-4 线刻边璋通长54.2cm，属第三件",
    "sources": [
     "四川省文物局藏品条目（wwj.sc.gov.cn 2021-09-10）",
     "四川省文旅局宣传文（wwj.sc.gov.cn 2020-05-19）",
     "人民网文化频道 2018-07-31",
     "川研院《三星堆古蜀王国的山崇拜》论文 PDF"
    ],
    "decision": "页面新增 #a04-specimen 选件卡，列四源四行与两条拍摄路径；不改 A04 落位与 A/B/C 判定",
    "page_anchor": "#a04-specimen"
   }
  ],
  "policy": "本页引文的每一次字形/句读/异文判定都要落到一条可打开的来源清单；改动留在页面上，不静默修订",
  "grade_note": "改正字形不等于升格证据等级：整理本电子文本仍属二手，A 级含义是「可逐字核对」而非「校勘定本」"
 }
}